A Triumph of Surgery Class 10 Extra Questions and Answers Free PDF Download
FAQs on CBSE Important Questions for Class 10 English Footprints Without Feet A Triumph of Surgery - 2025-26
1. What are the most important questions from 'A Triumph of Surgery' Class 10 for 2025–26 CBSE exams?
Some important questions for Chapter 1, 'A Triumph of Surgery', include:
- Describe Tricki’s initial condition and the reason behind his poor health. (3 marks)
- How does Mr. Herriot’s practical approach lead to Tricki’s recovery? (5 marks)
- Discuss the role of Mrs. Pumphrey in Tricki’s health problems. (3 marks)
- What is the significance of the title ‘A Triumph of Surgery’? (4 marks)
2. Why is Tricki’s treatment in 'A Triumph of Surgery' considered a ‘triumph’? (CBSE 2024, HOTS)
The treatment is a ‘triumph’ because Tricki’s health is restored not by complex surgery but by a disciplined routine and proper care. This highlights the value of restraint and balanced pet care, which was underestimated by his indulgent owner. The success comes from understanding and addressing the real cause of his illness.
3. How does Mrs. Pumphrey’s way of caring for Tricki reflect a common misconception about responsible pet ownership? (Expected, 3 marks)
Mrs. Pumphrey believes that giving Tricki rich food and indulgence equals love and good care. This misconception leads to Tricki’s obesity and ill health, showing that over-pampering pets can be harmful rather than beneficial. Proper pet care requires routine, balanced diet, and exercise.
4. Explain, with reference to 'A Triumph of Surgery', the importance of moderation in caring for animals. (Frequently asked, 5 marks)
The chapter shows that moderation is crucial in pet care. Tricki’s recovery results from a simple diet and routine exercise, rather than excessive pampering. Overindulgence, as practiced by Mrs. Pumphrey, leads to health problems while balanced care ensures well-being.
5. What changes take place in Tricki's behaviour after staying at Mr. Herriot’s surgery? (2025 Prediction, 3 marks)
After admission, Tricki transitions from being lethargic, overweight, and uninterested to becoming active, playful, and energetic. He eats normally, enjoys playing with other dogs, and regains his health rapidly due to moderation and daily exercise.
6. Describe how Mr. Herriot’s understanding of animal psychology helps Tricki recover. (Higher Order, 4 marks)
Mr. Herriot uses his knowledge of animals to recognize that Tricki’s problems are behavioral and lifestyle-related, not medical. He removes unhealthy luxuries, gives Tricki time to adjust, and encourages socialization and exercise, leading to a natural, healthy recovery.
7. Explain why CBSE board examiners consider the theme of responsible pet care highly examinable in 'A Triumph of Surgery'. (Examiner’s Choice, 3 marks)
Responsible pet care aligns with life skills and value-based questions favored in CBSE assessments. The story gives a clear example of how well-intentioned actions can become counterproductive, highlighting lessons on balance, self-control, and practical care—all key evaluative criteria for CBSE important questions.
8. What lesson should pet owners learn from Tricki’s story in 'A Triumph of Surgery'? (Repeated 2023/2024, 5 marks)
Pet owners must understand that love does not mean overindulgence. Balanced diet, regular exercise, and discipline are required for pet health. Excess of affection, especially in the form of unhealthy treats, can be detrimental.
9. How does humour play a role in conveying the moral of the story 'A Triumph of Surgery'? (Application, 4 marks)
James Herriot uses humour through Mrs. Pumphrey’s exaggerated actions and beliefs, and through the contrast between her worries and Mr. Herriot’s practical approach. This makes the lesson about moderation memorable and engaging for students.
10. Compare and contrast Mr. Herriot’s and Mrs. Pumphrey’s approaches to Tricki’s health. (CBSE tendency, 4 marks)
Mr. Herriot relies on discipline, routine, and experience to treat Tricki, while Mrs. Pumphrey believes in luxurious pampering, extra treats, and emotional attachment. The contrast shows that scientific, practical care is more effective than sentimental overindulgence.
11. In what ways does the story 'A Triumph of Surgery' illustrate the consequences of excess in daily life? (Value-based, 3 marks)
The story demonstrates that excess, even in care or kindness, can lead to negative outcomes. Tricki’s illness results from excess, and only moderation restores balance—an important lesson for both pet care and life situations in general.
12. Why does Tricki’s owner fail to notice his health deteriorating, according to the story? (Exam blind-spot, 3 marks)
Mrs. Pumphrey’s deep emotional attachment and constant indulgence blind her to Tricki’s problems. Her inability to see the unhealthy effects of her pampering is a key point for students to analyse in exam responses.
13. What role does discipline play in the recovery of Tricki as per 'A Triumph of Surgery'? (Conceptual, 3 marks)
Discipline—through a measured routine, fixed diet, and exercise—proves essential in Tricki’s recovery. It replaces excess with structure and moderation, leading to both physical and behavioral improvement.
14. Suggest how CBSE students should approach 5-mark questions from 'A Triumph of Surgery' for full marks in 2025–26. (Exam strategy, 5 marks)
Focus on:
- Answering all parts—cover cause, effect, and solution
- Using examples from the story (e.g., rich food, pampering, exercise)
- Maintaining structure—introduction, explanation, conclusion
- Using CBSE board language (refer to examiner’s marking scheme)

















