A Photograph Class 11 Questions and Answers - Free PDF Download
FAQs on NCERT Solutions For Class 11 English Hornbill (Poem) Chapter 1 A Photograph - 2025-26
1. Where can I find accurate NCERT Solutions for the Class 11 English poem, 'A Photograph'?
Vedantu provides detailed and accurate NCERT Solutions for Class 11 English Hornbill Chapter 1 poem, 'A Photograph'. These solutions are crafted by subject matter experts and strictly follow the CBSE 2025-26 guidelines, ensuring students receive correct, step-by-step explanations for all the questions in the textbook.
2. How do the NCERT Solutions for Class 11 English Chapter 1 explain the three distinct stages in 'A Photograph'?
The NCERT Solutions systematically break down the poem's structure into its three key stages, helping students formulate a complete answer. The solutions explain:
- Stage 1: The mother's childhood (a girl of twelve), as captured in the photograph.
- Stage 2: The mother's middle age, twenty or thirty years later, laughing at the snapshot with the poet.
- Stage 3: The period after the mother's death, where the photograph becomes a silent memory for the poet.
3. What is the central theme of 'A Photograph' as per the CBSE syllabus?
As per the CBSE curriculum, the NCERT Solutions explain that the central theme of 'A Photograph' is the poignant exploration of memory, loss, and the passage of time. The solutions guide students on how to elaborate on the transient nature of human life contrasted with the seeming permanence of nature (the sea) and the way photographs capture fleeting moments.
4. Who is the poet of 'A Photograph' in the Class 11 Hornbill textbook?
The poem 'A Photograph' from the NCERT Class 11 Hornbill textbook is written by Shirley Toulson. The NCERT solutions often provide this context to help students correctly attribute the work when answering questions.
5. What key literary devices in 'A Photograph' do the NCERT Solutions help identify?
The NCERT Solutions help students identify and explain key literary devices used in the poem. The correct method to answer such questions involves pointing out devices like:
- Alliteration: in 'terribly transient feet' and 'silence silences'.
- Oxymoron: in 'laboured ease'.
- Transferred Epithet: in 'terribly transient feet', where 'transient' describes human life, not just feet.
6. Why is a step-by-step approach, like in the NCERT Solutions, useful for explaining the line 'its silence silences'?
A step-by-step approach is crucial because the line 'its silence silences' has layered meanings. NCERT Solutions guide you to first explain the literal silence (the photograph cannot speak), and then the profound, emotional silence it creates in the poet, signifying the finality of her mother's death and her inability to share the memory. This structured method ensures a comprehensive answer that covers both the literary device (alliteration/paradox) and its thematic significance.
7. How do NCERT Solutions help structure a high-scoring answer on the contrast between transient human life and the permanent sea?
NCERT Solutions provide a model structure for this answer by guiding students to:
- First, introduce the core contrast as a central theme.
- Second, use specific evidence from the poem, such as the line about the sea which 'appears to have changed less'.
- Third, explain how the 'terribly transient feet' of the girls highlight human mortality.
- Finally, conclude by summarising how this contrast emphasizes the poem's message about loss and the passage of time.
8. Beyond just providing answers, how does using NCERT Solutions for 'A Photograph' improve answer-writing skills for the exam?
Using these NCERT Solutions improves answer-writing skills by demonstrating the correct CBSE pattern. They teach students how to integrate keywords, quote directly from the text to support their points, and structure their thoughts logically. This moves beyond simple comprehension to mastering the technique of crafting well-argued, evidence-based answers that are valued highly in examinations.
9. What common mistakes in interpreting the mother's past vs. the poet's present are clarified by NCERT Solutions?
A common mistake is simply stating that both are sad. The NCERT Solutions clarify the nuanced difference: the mother's past loss was her bygone childhood joy (which she laughed at later), while the poet's present loss is her mother's laughter itself. The solutions help articulate that both experiences of loss are connected by memory (the photograph), but they are fundamentally different in nature—one is a nostalgic memory, and the other is a painful, final absence.
10. How can a student correctly solve questions related to the tone of 'A Photograph' using the method shown in NCERT Solutions?
To correctly solve questions about the poem's tone, NCERT Solutions demonstrate a method of focusing on word choice and imagery. For 'A Photograph', the solutions would guide a student to identify the tone as nostalgic and melancholic. To justify this, one must cite the poet's fondness in describing her mother's 'sweet face' and the deep sense of loss conveyed through the powerful final line, 'its silence silences'. This method ensures the answer is analytical, not just a simple statement.











